vs

Click on the breeds above to change the breed you want to compare.

Compare Border Collie and Irish Setter side by side: temperament, energy, trainability, apartment fit, shedding, lifespan, weight and free adoption listings.

Breed traits

Character & behavior

Energy level

Playfulness

Intelligence

Trainability

Protectiveness

Sociability

Can stay alone

Lifestyle fit

Apartment-friendly

Good with kids

Yes

Good for first-time owners

Yes

Shedding

Noise level

Exercise needs

Physical & general

Life span

12–15 years

Weight

14–20 kg

25–32 kg

Height

46–56 cm

61–69 cm

Origin

United Kingdom

Ireland

Grooming effort

Nutrition sensitivity

Health risk

Heat tolerance

Cold tolerance

The Border Collie and Irish Setter are both energetic and intelligent breeds, but they cater to different lifestyles and preferences. The Border Collie, originating from the United Kingdom, is known for its high trainability and intelligence, making it an excellent choice for experienced owners seeking a highly active companion. In contrast, the Irish Setter, hailing from Ireland, is also energetic but is more sociable and friendly, making it suitable for first-time dog owners. Both breeds have similar lifespans and exercise needs, but their differences in size, trainability, and sociability can influence a potential owner's decision.

Border Collie — Advantages

High intelligence and trainability
Good with kids
Moderate shedding level
Adaptable to cold climates
Strong exercise needs for active owners

Disadvantages

Not suitable for first-time owners
Requires significant exercise
Can be noisy
Not apartment-friendly
Moderate protectiveness

Irish Setter — Advantages

Good for first-time owners
Highly sociable and friendly
Good with kids
Lower noise level
Moderate exercise needs

Disadvantages

Larger size may require more space
Slightly less trainable than Border Collie
Moderate grooming difficulty
Lower tolerance for cold climates
Higher health risks