vs

Click on the breeds above to change the breed you want to compare.

Compare Hokkaido and Irish Setter side by side: temperament, energy, trainability, apartment fit, shedding, lifespan, weight and free adoption listings.

Breed traits

Character & behavior

Energy level

Playfulness

Intelligence

Trainability

Protectiveness

Sociability

Can stay alone

Lifestyle fit

Apartment-friendly

Good with kids

Yes

Good for first-time owners

Yes

Shedding

Noise level

Exercise needs

Physical & general

Life span

12–15 years

Weight

25–35 kg

25–32 kg

Height

46–56 cm

61–69 cm

Origin

Japan

Ireland

Grooming effort

Nutrition sensitivity

Health risk

Heat tolerance

Cold tolerance

The Irish Setter and Hokkaido are both medium to large-sized breeds with similar lifespans, but they differ in several key aspects. The Irish Setter, originating from Ireland, is known for its high energy and sociability, making it an excellent choice for active families. In contrast, the Hokkaido, hailing from Japan, has a strong protective instinct and is better suited for owners who may not be first-time pet owners. While both breeds are good with kids, their temperaments and training needs vary significantly. The Irish Setter is more playful and trainable, whereas the Hokkaido requires a more experienced handler due to its protective nature. Additionally, the Hokkaido has a higher tolerance for cold climates, making it a better fit for colder regions. Understanding these differences can help potential owners make an informed decision based on their lifestyle and environment.

Hokkaido — Advantages

Strong protective instincts, making it a good watchdog.
Higher tolerance for cold climates, suitable for colder regions.
Moderate grooming difficulty, easier to maintain.
Good with kids, making it a family-friendly option.

Disadvantages

Requires a more experienced owner due to its protective nature.
Lower sociability, may not be as playful as the Irish Setter.
Can stay alone for longer periods, but still prefers companionship.
Not ideal for first-time owners.

Irish Setter — Advantages

High energy level, great for active families.
Excellent sociability, enjoys being around people.
Good with kids, making it a family-friendly option.
Suitable for first-time owners due to its trainability.
Playful nature adds joy to family activities.

Disadvantages

Can struggle with being left alone, requiring companionship.
Not apartment-friendly due to high exercise needs.
Moderate grooming difficulty, needing regular maintenance.
May have a higher shedding level compared to some breeds.