vs
Click on the breeds above to change the breed you want to compare.
Compare Irish Setter and Border Collie side by side: temperament, energy, trainability, apartment fit, shedding, lifespan, weight and free adoption listings.
Breed traits
Character & behavior
Energy level
Playfulness
Intelligence
Trainability
Protectiveness
Sociability
Can stay alone
Lifestyle fit
Apartment-friendly
No
No
Good with kids
Yes
Yes
Good for first-time owners
Yes
No
Shedding
Noise level
Exercise needs
Physical & general
Life span
12–15 years
12–15 years
Weight
25–32 kg
14–20 kg
Height
61–69 cm
46–56 cm
Origin
Ireland
United Kingdom
Grooming effort
Nutrition sensitivity
Health risk
Heat tolerance
Cold tolerance
The Border Collie and Irish Setter are both energetic and intelligent breeds, but they cater to different lifestyles and preferences. The Border Collie, originating from the United Kingdom, is known for its high trainability and intelligence, making it an excellent choice for experienced owners seeking a highly active companion. In contrast, the Irish Setter, hailing from Ireland, is also energetic but is more sociable and friendly, making it suitable for first-time dog owners. Both breeds have similar lifespans and exercise needs, but their differences in size, trainability, and sociability can influence a potential owner's decision.
Irish Setter — Advantages
Good for first-time owners
Highly sociable and friendly
Good with kids
Lower noise level
Moderate exercise needs
Highly sociable and friendly
Good with kids
Lower noise level
Moderate exercise needs
Disadvantages
Larger size may require more space
Slightly less trainable than Border Collie
Moderate grooming difficulty
Lower tolerance for cold climates
Higher health risks
Slightly less trainable than Border Collie
Moderate grooming difficulty
Lower tolerance for cold climates
Higher health risks
Border Collie — Advantages
High intelligence and trainability
Good with kids
Moderate shedding level
Adaptable to cold climates
Strong exercise needs for active owners
Good with kids
Moderate shedding level
Adaptable to cold climates
Strong exercise needs for active owners
Disadvantages
Not suitable for first-time owners
Requires significant exercise
Can be noisy
Not apartment-friendly
Moderate protectiveness
Requires significant exercise
Can be noisy
Not apartment-friendly
Moderate protectiveness
Frequently Asked Questions
Which breed is better for active families?
Both breeds are suitable for active families, but the Border Collie may require more exercise and mental stimulation.
Are these breeds good with children?
Yes, both the Border Collie and Irish Setter are good with kids.
Can I keep either breed in an apartment?
Neither breed is considered apartment-friendly due to their energy levels and space requirements.
How do their grooming needs compare?
The Border Collie has a lower grooming difficulty compared to the Irish Setter.
Which breed is easier to train?
The Border Collie is generally easier to train due to its higher intelligence and trainability.
free Irish Setter adoption listings
not compatible with my current routine
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
1258 views
Irish puppies for adoption
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
61 views
Irish setter, lots of energy
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
1100 views
Adopting an energetic Irish Setter
Male
Educated
Free Adoption
1503 views
free Border Collie adoption listings
Cachorros Border Collie de aspecto saludable
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
256 views
Beautiful Border Collie Puppies
Male
Educated
Free Adoption
294 views
Border terrier dogs
Male
Educated
Free Adoption
403 views
Border collie puppies
Male
Educated
Free Adoption
433 views
Border Collie Welpen
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
373 views
Well Trained Border Collie puppies WhatsApp:( +63-945-135-8253 )
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
279 views