vs
Click on the breeds above to change the breed you want to compare.
Compare Irish Setter and Newfoundland side by side: temperament, energy, trainability, apartment fit, shedding, lifespan, weight and free adoption listings.
Breed traits
Character & behavior
Energy level
Playfulness
Intelligence
Trainability
Protectiveness
Sociability
Can stay alone
Lifestyle fit
Apartment-friendly
No
No
Good with kids
Yes
Yes
Good for first-time owners
Yes
No
Shedding
Noise level
Exercise needs
Physical & general
Life span
12–15 years
8–10 years
Weight
25–32 kg
45–68 kg
Height
61–69 cm
66–71 cm
Origin
Ireland
Canada
Grooming effort
Nutrition sensitivity
Health risk
Heat tolerance
Cold tolerance
The Newfoundland and the Irish Setter are both beloved dog breeds, each with unique characteristics that cater to different lifestyles. The Newfoundland, originating from Canada, is known for its impressive size and strength, making it an excellent swimmer and a natural protector. This breed is particularly sociable and good with children, making it a family favorite. In contrast, the Irish Setter, hailing from Ireland, is recognized for its energetic and playful demeanor, ideal for active families and those who enjoy outdoor activities. While both breeds are friendly and sociable, they differ significantly in energy levels, lifespan, and overall care requirements. Understanding these differences can help potential owners choose the breed that best fits their lifestyle and preferences.
Irish Setter — Advantages
Longer lifespan (12-15 years)
Good for first-time owners
Very playful and energetic
High sociability
Moderate grooming needs
Good for first-time owners
Very playful and energetic
High sociability
Moderate grooming needs
Disadvantages
Higher exercise needs
Less protective than Newfoundland
Can be sensitive to heat
Not suitable for very cold climates
May require more attention to training
Less protective than Newfoundland
Can be sensitive to heat
Not suitable for very cold climates
May require more attention to training
Newfoundland — Advantages
Good with kids
Sociable and friendly
Strong protective instincts
Moderate exercise needs
Excellent for cold climates
Sociable and friendly
Strong protective instincts
Moderate exercise needs
Excellent for cold climates
Disadvantages
Shorter lifespan (8-10 years)
Not suitable for first-time owners
Can struggle with separation anxiety
Requires regular grooming
Heavy shedding
Not suitable for first-time owners
Can struggle with separation anxiety
Requires regular grooming
Heavy shedding
Frequently Asked Questions
Which breed is better for families with children?
Both breeds are good with kids, but the Newfoundland has strong protective instincts.
How much exercise do these breeds need?
Newfoundlands require moderate exercise, while Irish Setters need more vigorous activity.
Are either of these breeds suitable for first-time dog owners?
The Irish Setter is generally more suitable for first-time owners compared to the Newfoundland.
What is the lifespan of these breeds?
Newfoundlands typically live 8-10 years, whereas Irish Setters have a longer lifespan of 12-15 years.
How do they handle extreme weather conditions?
Newfoundlands tolerate cold climates well, while Irish Setters are more sensitive to heat and do better in moderate conditions.
free Irish Setter adoption listings
not compatible with my current routine
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
1111 views
Irish setter, lots of energy
Male
Not Educated
Free Adoption
941 views
Adopting an energetic Irish Setter
Male
Educated
Free Adoption
1364 views
